a woman sneezing next to air purifier and humidifier

Air Purifier vs. Humidifier: Which is Better for Allergies?

by Karl von Luckwald / January 16, 2024

When it comes to managing allergies, choosing the right device for your home can be a game-changer.

Two popular options are air purifiers and humidifiers. Both have their unique benefits, but which one is better for allergies? Keep reading and you’ll find out.

So, Are Air purifiers or Humidifiers better for allergies?

Air purifiers with HEPA filters remove airborne allergens and are ideal for respiratory allergies, while humidifiers add moisture to relieve dry-air symptoms. Use both for optimal symptom relief.

Understanding Air Purifiers

  • What They Do: An air purifier cleans the air and improves indoor air quality. They suck in air, filter out pollutants like dust, bacteria, viruses, pollen, pet dander, mold spores, and smoke, and then release clean air back into the room.
  • How They Help with Allergies: Air purifiers can significantly reduce your allergy symptoms since they remove allergens from the air. They will provide a germ and pollutant-free environment in your home. Just make sure to choose an air purifier that suits your needs.
The Sqair air purifier with beautiful design next to a couch in a living room
Air purifiers are great tools for cleaning the air from airborne contaminants

Air Purifier Types

HEPA Air Purifiers

  • How They Work: HEPA filters (High-Efficiency Particulate Air) in these purifiers can trap extremely small particles, including those thousands of times smaller than a human hair. HEPA filters are the best choice to decrease indoor air pollution as they’re able to capture up to 100% of all pollutants, according to NASA.
  • Benefits: A HEPA filter is highly efficient at capturing a wide range of pollutants, especially allergens like pollen, dust mites, and pet dander.
  • Best For: An air purifier containing a HEPA filter is great for individuals with allergies or asthma, as it provides excellent filtration of airborne allergens.
a person inserting a hepa filter into an air purifier
HEPA filters capture particles and are great against allergies

Air Purifiers with Carbon Filters

  • How They Work: An air purifier containing an activated carbon filter can help absorb gases, chemicals, and odors from the air.
  • Benefits: Effective at removing smells and chemical vapors, providing a fresher indoor environment.
  • Best For: Those looking to eliminate household odors, smoke, or chemical pollutants. Carbon filters don’t capture allergen particles.
a person inserting a carbon filter into an air purifier
Carbon filters absorb smell and odors but can’t capture allergens

UV Air Purifiers

  • How They Work: Utilize UV (ultraviolet) light to neutralize airborne pathogens like viruses and bacteria.
  • Benefits: They can aid in reducing the spread of airborne diseases, although their effectiveness is limited.
  • Best For: People wanting an added level of protection against germs, but should be used in conjunction with more effective particle-filtering purifiers.
a close up shot of blue uv lights
UV light in air purifiers is usually too weak to have a significant effect

Air Purifiers with Ionizers

  • How They Work: An air purifier using ionizer technology releases negative ions that attach to positively charged particles (like dust), causing them to fall onto surfaces.
  • Benefits: Can help reduce the presence of certain pollutants, but they don’t remove them from the air.
  • Best For: Supplemental use in reducing indoor pollution, but caution is advised due to ozone production.
a graphic of an air purifier shooting out ionizers
Ionizers don’t capture particles but move them around

    Understanding Humidifiers

    • What They Do: Humidifiers add moisture to the air, which is particularly beneficial in dry climates or during winter months when indoor air can become excessively dry. By emitting water vapor or steam into the air, they help maintain a comfortable level of humidity in your living space.
    • How They Help with Allergies: Dry air can aggravate nasal passages, throat, and skin, worsening allergies and causing discomfort. A humidifier helps by maintaining balanced humidity levels, and soothing irritated respiratory tissues. This leads to relief from dry cough, itchy eyes, and nasal congestion. Optimal humidity also helps preserve the skin’s natural barriers, reducing allergic responses and enhancing comfort in dry environments.

    Types of Humidifiers:

    a closeup shot of a humidifier on a table
    Humidifiers moisture the air

    Evaporative Humidifiers

    • How They Work: These humidifiers have a fan that blows air through a moistened filter or wick. As the air passes through the wet material, it picks up moisture and then circulates this moist air throughout the room.
    • Benefits: They are self-regulating, meaning as the humidity in the room increases, the humidifier’s ability to add moisture decreases. This prevents over-humidification.
    • Best For: People looking for a low-maintenance option, as they are easy to use and clean.

    Ultrasonic Humidifiers

    • How They Work: These use ultrasonic vibrations to produce a fine mist of water, which is then expelled to add moisture to the air. The vibrations are so fast that you don’t hear them.
    • Benefits: They are very quiet, making them ideal for bedrooms. They also come in cool or warm mist options.
    • Best For: Those who need a quiet humidifier, like light sleepers, or for use in a baby’s room.

    Steam Vaporizers

    • How They Work: These humidifiers heat water to create steam, which is then cooled slightly before being released into the air.
    • Benefits: Since the water is boiled, the steam is generally cleaner. This type can also be used with medicated inhalants for additional relief.
    • Best For: People who want a more hygienic option or need a humidifier that can also disperse medications for respiratory relief.

    Air Purifier vs. Humidifier for Allergies

    Both air purifiers and humidifiers offer unique benefits to tackle allergic reactions. Understanding their roles can help you decide which one, or a combination of both, is right for your needs.

    The Case for Air Purifiers:

    • Function: Air purifiers work by pulling in air and passing it through filters to remove allergens and other pollutants.
    • Benefits: Air purifiers are highly effective in trapping pollutants such as pollen, pet dander, and dust mites, which are common allergens. This reduction of airborne allergens helps ease symptoms in individuals with allergies and asthma. Scientific studies have consistently validated the benefits of air purifiers for allergy sufferers.
    • Ideal For: Those who suffer from respiratory allergies or asthma, as air purifiers can make breathing easier by cleaning the air.
    blast mini air purifier in a bedroom
    Air purifiers filter allergens pollutants providing a healthy living environment

    The Case for Humidifiers:

    • Function: Humidifiers improve air quality by adding moisture to the air, which can help in environments where the air is dry.
    • Benefits: By maintaining a balanced humidity level, humidifiers can prevent the dryness that often aggravates allergy symptoms. They can relieve discomforts such as sore throats, itchy eyes, and dry skin.
    • Ideal For: Individuals living in dry climates or experiencing allergies that flare up in dry indoor conditions.
    a humidifier releasing steam into the air
    Use humidifiers in dry areas to keep the air moisturized

    Choosing Air Purifiers or Humidifiers for Allergies?

    Consider Your Allergy Triggers:

    • If airborne allergens are your main concern, an air purifier is more suitable as it directly removes these particles from the air.
    • If your allergies are exacerbated by dry air, leading to symptoms like dry coughs or itchy skin, a humidifier is likely to provide more relief.

    Can You Use Air Purifiers and Humidifiers Together?

    Combining an air purifier with a humidifier can be an excellent strategy for comprehensive allergy relief. The air purifier provides clean air, while the humidifier maintains a comfortable level of humidity, addressing both indoor pollution and the effects of dry air.

    Tips for Effective Use

    Air Purifiers:

    • Placement: Position them in frequently used areas such as bedrooms or living rooms for maximum benefit.
    • Maintenance: Regular filter replacement or cleaning is crucial for keeping the air purifier effective.

    Humidifiers:

    • Usage: Be cautious not to overuse, as excessive humidity can encourage mold and mildew growth.
    • Cleaning: Regular cleaning is essential to prevent the buildup of bacteria and mold spores in the device. The American Academy of Asthma and Immunology recommends to keep humidity levels between 40-50%.

    Bottom Line

    Air purifiers excel at capturing airborne allergens, making them suitable for respiratory allergy sufferers. Humidifiers, on the other hand, alleviate symptoms caused by dry air, such as sore throats and dry skin. For comprehensive allergy relief, consider using both devices in tandem.

    This approach addresses both indoor pollution and dry air effects, offering a more holistic solution to managing allergies in various environments. Regular maintenance and correct usage are key for the effectiveness of both air purifiers and humidifiers.

    FAQ

    The choice between an air purifier and a humidifier depends on your specific allergy triggers. An air purifier is more suitable for removing airborne allergens, while a humidifier is better for alleviating symptoms caused by dry air.

    A humidifier is generally better for sinuses, especially in dry environments, as it adds moisture to the air and can alleviate sinus irritation. However, if sinus issues are related to airborne allergens, an air purifier might be more beneficial.

    Yes, air purifiers help with allergies. They work by removing allergens like pollen, pet hair, and dust mites from the air, thereby alleviating allergy symptoms.

    Yes, humidifiers can help with allergies, especially in dry conditions. They add moisture to the air, preventing dryness that can aggravate allergy symptoms like sore throat and itchy eyes.

    For allergies, a humidifier is generally best in dry conditions, as it adds moisture to the air and alleviates dryness-related symptoms. A dehumidifier might be beneficial in overly humid conditions where mold and dust mites thrive.

    Yes, sleeping with a humidifier can be beneficial if you have allergies, particularly in dry environments. It helps maintain a comfortable level of humidity, which can soothe the respiratory system and alleviate allergy symptoms.

    Use a humidifier for allergies when the air is dry, and you experience symptoms like dry cough, itchy eyes, or sore throat. It’s particularly helpful in dry climates or during winter.

    Yes, dry air can make allergies worse by irritating the nasal passages and throat, exacerbating allergic reactions.

    Humidifiers can help clear sinuses by adding moisture to the air, which can soothe and reduce irritation in the nasal passages and sinuses, especially in dry conditions.

    Karl von Luckwald

    Karl von Luckwald

    Since moving to Thailand in 2019, Karl noticed the lack of scientific integrity in air purifier and water filter reviews. In response, he founded WE DO AIR to champion unbiased, science-based evaluations and empower consumers to make better-informed decisions.

    Have a question? Add us on Line
    Click to Chat With Us!